YouTube
Instagram
Facebook
TikTok
Episode 12: How Acceptable is "Hands Replacement"?
Kenji
Master! This watch has a beautifully aged dial, it's fantastic!
But the hands are like a sparkling new employee!
But the hands are like a sparkling new employee!
Master
Hmm.
That "hands-only-look-young" feeling, it could be a case of replaced hands.
That "hands-only-look-young" feeling, it could be a case of replaced hands.
Kenji
Huh, replaced hands? Are watch hands that important?
Master
(They're a crucial part that defines a watch's face and tells time...)
① What is hands replacement? A small part that changes the "face" of a watch
Master
Hands replacement, as the name suggests, is when the original hands have been swapped out for different ones.
They might be replaced during manufacturer repairs, or swapped during later servicing.
It might seem minor at first glance, but it significantly alters the overall atmosphere of the watch.
They might be replaced during manufacturer repairs, or swapped during later servicing.
It might seem minor at first glance, but it significantly alters the overall atmosphere of the watch.
What changes with hands replacement
- Visual Impression: The feel of the dial and hands changes
- Lume Consistency: Color differences between hands and indices tend to stand out
- Originality: Whether it matches the original specifications impacts its valuation
- Appraisal Price: Can make a difference, especially for vintage pieces
* "Replaced hands" does not mean "fake." However, the fact that it's "not original" is important.
Kenji
I see.
So hands are like bangs.
They're part of the face, so even a slight change can "drastically alter the vibe."
So hands are like bangs.
They're part of the face, so even a slight change can "drastically alter the vibe."
② Why is it easy to overlook? If you think "the dial is the star," you might miss incongruous hands
Master
Most people look at the dial first.
The logo, the aging, the color, the atmosphere... it's natural for their eyes to go there.
But the hands, despite being small, are a crucial part that changes the overall "vibe".
So you shouldn't overlook them.
The logo, the aging, the color, the atmosphere... it's natural for their eyes to go there.
But the hands, despite being small, are a crucial part that changes the overall "vibe".
So you shouldn't overlook them.
Here's the pitfall:
Even if the dial is good, if only the hands are new, the overall balance can be off.
Especially for vintage models, it's a major plus if the dial, hands, and lume have aged together consistently.
Even if the dial is good, if only the hands are new, the overall balance can be off.
Especially for vintage models, it's a major plus if the dial, hands, and lume have aged together consistently.
Kenji
Got it.
It's like wearing a perfect suit but a tie for your entrance ceremony.
If only the accessories are too new, the whole look suddenly feels awkward.
It's like wearing a perfect suit but a tie for your entrance ceremony.
If only the accessories are too new, the whole look suddenly feels awkward.
③ What to look for? "Incongruity" can easily arise from length, shape, and lume color
Master
It's not just one thing to look for.
When examining the hands, mainly focus on these points.
Length Shape Thickness Lume Color
If the minute hand is slightly too long, the tip shape is different, or the lume is too white...
A collection of these "slight misalignments" can create a sense of incongruity.
When examining the hands, mainly focus on these points.
Length Shape Thickness Lume Color
If the minute hand is slightly too long, the tip shape is different, or the lume is too white...
A collection of these "slight misalignments" can create a sense of incongruity.
Master's Observation Points
- Length: Are the minute and second hands in their correct relative positions?
- Shape: Do the tip, base, and shape of the lume cutout match the era's specifications?
- Thickness/Texture: Do they look too new for the dial's atmosphere?
- Lume Color: Is there too much of a color discrepancy between the indices and the hands?
* Since genuine specifications differ by model and year, don't assume a difference based on a "feeling"; always confirm specifications for each reference.
Kenji
Ah, it's like one person in the class photo having perfectly white teeth.
It suddenly catches your eye.
It suddenly catches your eye.
④ Is it okay if the manufacturer replaces them? "Peace of mind" and "originality" are separate issues
Kenji
But if they're replaced by the manufacturer,
it's proper and reassuring, right?
it's proper and reassuring, right?
Master
Of course, there's a sense of security as a functional item.
Because it's been serviced through proper channels.
However, that's separate from the evaluation of originality.
It's like putting brand new genuine seats in a classic car.
It becomes more comfortable. But it's on a different axis from the "original flavor."
Because it's been serviced through proper channels.
However, that's separate from the evaluation of originality.
It's like putting brand new genuine seats in a classic car.
It becomes more comfortable. But it's on a different axis from the "original flavor."
Kenji
So "practicality" and "originality" are different, then.
⑤ How to ask? Just "Have the hands been replaced?" isn't enough.
Kenji
Before buying, what should I ask?
Is "Have the hands been replaced?" too shallow?
Is "Have the hands been replaced?" too shallow?
Master
Good question.
It's best if you can ask this much.
"Are the hands original?
Are there any replacement or manufacturer repair records?
Is the lume consistent with the indices?
Can I see close-up photos of the dial, angled photos, and photos in dark or natural light?"
This will make it much easier to judge.
It's best if you can ask this much.
"Are the hands original?
Are there any replacement or manufacturer repair records?
Is the lume consistent with the indices?
Can I see close-up photos of the dial, angled photos, and photos in dark or natural light?"
This will make it much easier to judge.
Information to gather from questions
- Are the hands original?
- Are there any replacement/repair records?
- Lume consistency
- Photos from multiple angles and under various light sources
⑥ Risks and Concerns: Buying unknowingly often leads to regret of "the dial was good, but..."
Master
If you overlook hands replacement, this is likely to happen later.
・Difference in appraisal upon resale
・Believing "the good dial makes everything strong"
・Disadvantage in comparison in an originality-focused market
・If not explained, things get complicated when selling
In other words, if you only focus on the dial, the hands will assert themselves later.
・Difference in appraisal upon resale
・Believing "the good dial makes everything strong"
・Disadvantage in comparison in an originality-focused market
・If not explained, things get complicated when selling
In other words, if you only focus on the dial, the hands will assert themselves later.
Caution:
It can be difficult to judge the color and texture of hands from images alone.
The whiteness of the lume, the sheen of the hand surface, and reflections due to angle can easily differ from the actual item, so for high-value items, checking in person is safer.
It can be difficult to judge the color and texture of hands from images alone.
The whiteness of the lume, the sheen of the hand surface, and reflections due to angle can easily differ from the actual item, so for high-value items, checking in person is safer.
Kenji
So I was just
captivated by the superficial beauty, after all...
I might regret that later...
captivated by the superficial beauty, after all...
I might regret that later...
Conclusion: Hands replacement isn't "bad." But it changes the "overall vibe."
Master
The way to remember it is simple.
Hands are a small part. But their impact on the impression is not small.
For practical use, it can even be a plus.
But for collection and appraisal, consistency with the dial and originality are questioned.
So instead of thinking "I can look at the hands later,"
it's important to look at the whole face from the beginning.
Hands are a small part. But their impact on the impression is not small.
For practical use, it can even be a plus.
But for collection and appraisal, consistency with the dial and originality are questioned.
So instead of thinking "I can look at the hands later,"
it's important to look at the whole face from the beginning.
Kenji
From today, I won't
just say "That's a nice dial~" anymore.
I'll be looking to see, "Do those hands truly share the same history?"
just say "That's a nice dial~" anymore.
I'll be looking to see, "Do those hands truly share the same history?"
3 things you can do starting today to avoid hands replacement pitfalls:
- Don't judge by the dial alone; view the hands as "part of the face" too.
- Check the length, shape, and lume color of the hands.
- Always confirm replacement/repair history and request multiple photos.
* Especially for vintage models or those with many variations, the details of the hands can significantly affect the appraisal. For problematic pieces, confirming the year's specifications and consulting a trustworthy dealer is the safest approach.
![[AI Manga] Episode 13: How Far Can](http://commit-watch.co.jp/cdn/shop/articles/fc6125fa58b3c04001b6d4efad010fbc_7854ef40-49ed-4856-92ea-6a9d3aaa3763_360x360_crop_center.jpg?v=1776394804)
![[Manga] Episode 11: How Far Can You Go with a](http://commit-watch.co.jp/cdn/shop/articles/manga_10b_1280_b8eab7d6-5a27-4f5e-9965-7309b6fe991d_360x360_crop_center.jpg?v=1775129840)
![[Manga] Episode 10: How far is that](http://commit-watch.co.jp/cdn/shop/articles/manga_09_1280_a7b18430-3915-4603-9782-5870c8785479_360x360_crop_center.jpg?v=1774783407)
![[Manga] Episode 9: How Far Can You Go with That](http://commit-watch.co.jp/cdn/shop/articles/manga_09_1280_360x360_crop_center.jpg?v=1773918129)
![[Manga] Episode 8: Which warranty is covered by that](http://commit-watch.co.jp/cdn/shop/articles/manga_08_1280_35e5a1ff-4398-4b30-b2fa-3f99ec4952a1_360x360_crop_center.jpg?v=1773398394)